Blog

Early Settlement Panel (ESP) in NJ is the date that makes a lot of people anxious… and for understandable reasons. It’s on a court schedule. It’s mandatory once you’re sent there. And it can feel like you’re walking into a “mini‑trial.”

But here’s the truth we tell clients in our office: ESP is not a trial. It’s a structured settlement day designed to help you end (or at least narrow) the financial fight before you spend months preparing for trial-level litigation.

If you go in prepared, ESP can be the moment your case finally stops dragging. If you go in half‑prepared—or emotionally unready—you can leave with the same stalemate you walked in with, plus extra legal fees and even more frustration.

In this post, I’ll walk you through what ESP is, who’s involved, what happens on the day, what you should bring, and how to use it to actually move your divorce toward a settlement.

What an Early Settlement Panel (ESP) in NJ really is

An Early Settlement Panel is a court‑connected settlement event in a contested divorce. The goal is simple: help the parties resolve the “money issues” so they don’t have to try the case in front of a judge.

New Jersey courts describe ESP as part of the overall settlement system in divorce, and it’s often the first major structured opportunity to put real numbers on the table. In fact, the courts note that contested divorce cases are first reviewed by an ESP, where the panel recommends a settlement; if the issues remain unresolved, the court may then order economic mediation.

Also important: participation is mandatory once the judge refers the case to ESP, and the court expects the parties to take it seriously.

Think of ESP as a professional reality-check session. Not because you’re “wrong,” but because divorce cases tend to drift into extremes:

• One spouse assumes they’ll keep the house, pay no support, and split debt 50/50.
• The other spouse assumes they’ll get the house, long-term support, and an “unequal” distribution as punishment.

ESP is where those assumptions get tested against what typically happens in the Family Part.

What ESP is not

ESP is not a trial.

No witnesses get sworn in. Nobody is cross‑examined. The panel isn’t there to decide who was the better spouse. And it’s not the place where custody or parenting time usually gets resolved.

The court’s own divorce information separates these processes: custody/parenting time issues can be addressed through mediation, while economic issues go to ESP if they can’t be resolved.

So if your goal for ESP is “I want to explain what my spouse did,” you’ll almost certainly leave disappointed.

The goal is: What settlement would be fair and realistic, given the facts and the financial documents?

When ESP happens in the divorce timeline

ESP generally shows up after discovery (or near the end of discovery), and it’s often scheduled through a case management order in the normal flow of an FM (dissolution) case.

That matters for a practical reason: if discovery is unfinished, or if your finances aren’t documented, ESP becomes guesswork. And guesswork is where bad settlements come from.

Who sits on the Early Settlement Panel

The “panel” is not a judge.

Typically, the panel is made up of two experienced divorce attorneys who serve in a neutral role for the day, and they review the case and recommend a settlement.

In practice, you may also interact with:

• An ESP coordinator (court staff / program coordinator) who manages scheduling and submissions.
• Sometimes the judge (or staff) briefly at the start for general instructions, depending on the county’s process (this varies).

One detail clients like to hear up front: the panelists are there to help both sides move toward a resolution. They’re not “your” panelists or your spouse’s panelists.

What issues the ESP focuses on

ESP is about economic issues. That usually means things like:

• Alimony (or whether alimony should be paid at all)
• Child support (financial side—often with guideline calculations)
• Equitable distribution (how assets and debts are divided)
• Counsel fees (in appropriate cases)
• Other financial terms that need to be resolved to finalize the divorce

The NJ courts describe ESP as the first review point for contested cases and explain that unresolved financial disputes may then go to economic mediation.

Custody and parenting time are typically handled through different processes, and the court’s self-help divorce page makes that distinction clear.

What happens at an Early Settlement Panel day

Every county runs a little differently, and some counties may use in‑person, virtual, or hybrid formats. For example, Hudson County announced hybrid ESPs where panelists attend virtually and parties/attorneys attend in person.

But in most cases, the day follows a familiar rhythm.

Check-in and waiting

You or your attorney checks in. It’s common to wait—sometimes longer than people expect. ESP days often involve multiple cases on the docket.

This is one reason we tell clients to clear their schedule. Being rushed makes you more likely to make emotional decisions or reject reasonable proposals because you’re frustrated.

The panel reviews the submissions

Before your case is called, panelists review each side’s written submission and financial information.

This is where many cases either gain momentum or lose it.

If the submissions are organized, updated, and grounded in documents, the panel can focus on solutions. If the submissions are incomplete or inflated, the panel spends its time trying to figure out what’s real.

The attorneys present positions

Typically, attorneys do most of the talking. The panel may ask clarifying questions.

If you’re self-represented, you may speak more directly, but you still want to be concise and factual.

The panel deliberates and gives a recommendation

After hearing both sides, the panel gives a recommendation on a fair settlement approach.

That recommendation is not a court order. It’s guidance—often a strong reality check—but it doesn’t force either side to sign anything.

Negotiation and potential settlement

This is the part people underestimate.

Even if you don’t accept the panel recommendation word‑for‑word, the recommendation can move the parties closer. You may adjust proposals and settle later that day.

If you reach agreement on all terms, the settlement usually gets memorialized (how depends on the county, the judge’s availability, and whether additional documents must be drafted). If you settle partially, you preserve what’s resolved and identify the remaining issues.

Your ESP paperwork deadline is not optional

Here’s the practical warning that’s worth saying plainly.

Under the court’s ESP program information, both parties must submit their papers to the ESP coordinator and panelists at least five days before the hearing date, and failing to do so can result in serious consequences (including dismissal or paying the other side’s legal fees).

Different counties may have slightly different logistics, but the takeaway is the same: do not treat your ESP paperwork like something you can throw together the night before.

If you’re working with counsel, we build your submission early because you don’t want to walk in defensively. You want to walk in prepared.

What documents to bring to an Early Settlement Panel

You’ll hear different terms—“ESP submission,” “ESP memo,” “settlement statement.” Some counties use their own forms. The guiding principle is consistent:

Bring what the panel needs to understand your financial life and verify your numbers.

Start with the Case Information Statement

In New Jersey, the Family Part Case Information Statement (CIS) is the backbone of financial litigation. It’s where income, expenses, assets, debts, and lifestyle get laid out.

The CIS form itself emphasizes that it must be fully completed and that failure to file can lead to dismissal of pleadings; it also lists required attachments like tax returns, W‑2s/1099s, and recent paystubs.

Even when you already filed a CIS earlier in the case, ESP is not the time to rely on an old version. If your living situation or income changed, your CIS should reflect that.

The practical “bring it with you” list

Without turning this into a giant checklist, here are the documents that most commonly matter at ESP:

• Updated CIS (and your spouse’s CIS if exchanged)
• Most recent tax returns (and W‑2/1099/K‑1 forms)
• Recent paystubs (and proof of bonuses/commissions if relevant)
• Bank account statements (especially for accounts with large balances or unusual activity)
• Retirement account statements (401(k), pension, IRA, etc.)
• Mortgage statement and property tax/insurance information (if a home is involved)
• Any appraisals or valuations completed during discovery
• Credit card statements and loan statements for major debts
• Health insurance premium info and child-related costs (childcare, unreimbursed medical, etc.)
• If child support is on the table: a current guideline worksheet or at least the inputs you believe are accurate (income, overnights, childcare, insurance)

For child support resources, the courts provide links to guideline worksheets and related forms.

You don’t need to bring your entire filing cabinet. But you do want to bring enough that you can answer follow‑up questions without guessing.

How to prepare for ESP like you actually want it to work

If you only remember one thing, remember this:

ESP rewards people who know their numbers.

It’s hard to negotiate support or divide assets if you don’t have a clear picture of (a) what exists and (b) what it costs to live.

Know what you’re asking for, and why

It’s not enough to say, “I want alimony.”

The panel is going to want to understand: What are the incomes? What was the lifestyle? What are the budgets? What is realistic post‑divorce?

The same is true for equitable distribution. “I want the house” isn’t a plan. A plan includes:

• Who refinances (and when)?
• Who pays the mortgage and carrying costs until then?
• What happens if refinancing isn’t possible?
• How the equity is calculated (and on what valuation date)?

Prepare three settlement outcomes, not one demand

A negotiation usually fails because one side shows up with a single position and treats it like a moral principle.

A better approach is to arrive with a range:

• A preferred outcome
• A realistic compromise
• A fallback that still protects you

That doesn’t mean you’re weak. It means you’re prepared.

Decide what matters most to you before the day

ESP is not the day to “figure out” your priorities in real time.

Some people care most about monthly cash flow. Others care about keeping the home (even if it means less support). Others care about preserving retirement assets.

None of these priorities are “wrong,” but you should know yours before you’re sitting in a courthouse conference room (or on a video call) making life decisions quickly.

Get emotionally ready for a neutral opinion

One of the hardest moments for many clients is hearing a panel recommendation that doesn’t match their expectations.

If the panel says your request is unrealistic, it doesn’t mean the panel thinks you’re a bad person. It usually means the numbers and the law aren’t lining up the way you hoped.

This is why we treat ESP as a strategy day, not a validation day.

Is what happens at ESP confidential?

Clients ask this constantly, and it’s a fair question.

There are a few different “layers” to understand:

Settlement negotiations are generally protected from being used as proof

New Jersey Rule of Evidence 408 says that statements or conduct in settlement negotiations—including offers of compromise—are not admissible to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim, though there are exceptions when offered for another purpose.

So, speaking practically: you don’t want to be reckless in an ESP submission, but you should be able to negotiate without feeling like every sentence becomes trial evidence.

Court processes vary, so ask your attorney how your county handles it

The safest advice is this: treat your ESP submission like a professional document. Don’t exaggerate. Don’t insult. Don’t assume it’s a private diary entry.

But also don’t hold back from negotiating because you’re afraid a settlement offer will automatically be used against you. In most cases, that’s not how it works.

What happens if you do not settle at ESP?

Not settling at ESP doesn’t mean you “lost.” It means the case continues.

After ESP, if financial disputes remain, the court may order the parties into economic mediation, which is designed to help resolve property division and support issues.

The court’s economic mediation overview also explains that the first two hours of post‑ESP economic mediation are free, with costs after that typically paid by the parties.

Also, program guidelines and directives reflect that cases referred to economic mediation must first be referred to the Matrimonial Early Settlement Panel program.

Common mistakes we see at ESP (and how to avoid them)

Walking in with an outdated CIS

An outdated CIS can make you look unreliable, even if you’re not trying to hide anything.

If you moved out, changed jobs, started paying rent, lost a bonus, or took on new expenses—update it.

Treating ESP like a stage for grievances

I understand the impulse. Divorce often comes with betrayal, anger, and deep frustration.

But ESP is a numbers conversation. If you spend your time trying to prove your spouse is “the bad guy,” you miss the window to get a favorable financial outcome.

Refusing to negotiate because “a judge will see it my way”

Sometimes that’s true. Often it’s not.

Trials are uncertain, slow, and expensive. ESP is one of the few moments where you can receive a neutral recommendation without waiting months for a trial date.

Not bringing proof

If you claim an expense, have documentation.

If you claim an asset exists, have documentation.

If you claim your income is lower because business is down, be ready with records.

Settlement decisions are only as good as the information behind them.

How to use ESP to move your case toward settlement

Here’s what we aim for in our practice (especially in high-conflict matters): even if you don’t settle 100% at ESP, you should leave with progress.

That progress can look like:

• Agreement on the home value or the method for valuing it
• Agreement on how retirement accounts will be divided (even if the exact math is later)
• Agreement on a temporary support structure while a remaining issue gets resolved
• Agreement on the specific “missing pieces” needed to settle (e.g., an appraisal, a pension valuation, a vocational assessment)

The win isn’t always “sign today.” Sometimes the win is a narrower case with fewer landmines.

Final thoughts from a Bergen County divorce practice

ESP is one of those moments where preparation pays off fast.

When clients show up with an accurate CIS, clean financial records, and a settlement strategy, the conversation changes. It becomes less about posturing and more about solutions.

And that’s the point. The court’s own materials emphasize that settlement can shorten litigation time, save money, and reduce the emotional burden of a divorce trial.

If you’re approaching an ESP date and you’re not sure what your submission should look like—or you’re worried you’ll be pressured into a bad deal—get legal guidance at Sammarro & Zalarick before the deadline. The goal isn’t to “go along.” The goal is to settle smart, or to leave with a clear roadmap for the next step.

Note: This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and procedures change, and every case is different. For advice about your situation, speak with an attorney licensed in New Jersey.